Tampa Bay carrier reviews · Updated May 2026
Tampa auto insurance carriers — who prices your profile best.
Each carrier has a sweet spot. GEICO wins on clean records. USAA wins for military. State Farm wins on bundling. Progressive wins on telematics + SR-22. Pick the right carrier for YOUR profile — or compare all 12 in 90 seconds.
GEICO
$184/mo avg
Sweet spot
Clean record, mid-age, 12+ months continuous coverage
Read full review
Progressive
$215/mo avg
Sweet spot
Snapshot telematics drivers, SR-22 filers, lapsed coverage
Read full review
State Farm
$256/mo avg
Sweet spot
Bundlers (auto + home), multi-car households, long tenure
Read full review
Allstate
$289/mo avg
Sweet spot
Drivewise telematics, accident-forgiveness, mid-age clean records
Read full review
USAA
$142/mo avg
Sweet spot
MacDill AFB, military families, veterans, dependents
Read full review
Final step
Compare all 12 Tampa carriers in 60 seconds.
No SSN required. Same-day binding with FL-licensed agent.
- → Live carrier rates pulled this month
- → No SSN at quote, soft pull only
- → Same-day binding with FL-licensed agent
- → SR-22 / FR-44 / ITIN / lapsed coverage all welcome
Tampa quote · Step 1 of 6
Save up to $487/yr on Tampa car insurance.
17%
Complete
Start with your ZIP — Tampa Bay rates vary up to $64/mo by neighborhood. Compare 12+ carriers in 90 seconds. No SSN. No spam.
No SSN at quote FL-licensed agent Soft pull only